Question of Numbers

Menteri Luar Negeri, Dato' Seri Utama Dr. Rais...
Menteri Luar Negeri, Dato’ Seri Utama Dr. Rais Yatim (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Our extremely honest and trustworthy information minister – Dr Rais Yatimclaimed today that they were able to conclusively determine from image estimation techniques that there were only about 22,700 people gathered at Bersih 3.0 rally.

I think that our government has lost the forest for the trees.

Firstly, nobody believes in whatever official figures you quote any more as you have lost all credibility. In Bersih 1.0, you claimed that there were only about 4,000 people. Nobody believed you.

In Bersih 2.0, you claimed that it was smaller than Bersih 1.0 with only 5,000 people. Malaysia became the only place in the world where the immutable laws of mathematics have been violated – 5,000 is less than 4,000.

Also, the police managed to arrest a whopping 1,600 people – 30% of the crowd. That’s essentially one in every three person at the rally. I can tell you that no Malaysian can ever believe that our PDRM has such efficiency catching unarmed people.

Now you claim that there are only 22,700 people and I guess that the point is to show that this is the fringe minority who are making noise. All these mathemagic just beguiles the average Malaysian like me.

Does it matter whether it is 22,700 or 227,000? – No.

What matters is that:

  1. Bersih is growing. You cannot deny that. I can tell you that for every person that attended the rally, there are at least another 10 who’re unable to attend it due to various reasons and that they will be there for Bersih 4.0
  2. Bersih is able to pull in a truly 1Malaysia crowd. Maybe the UMNO birthday bash drew in huge crowds – but it was not a 1Malaysia event. Bersih is the single largest 1Malaysia event in Malaysia.
  3. Bersih attendees came on their own volition and under the threat of police arrests, tear gas, water cannons, police beatings, etc. Quantity isn’t the only thing that you should be concerned with – quality too.

So, what I’d like to say is that the numbers are not at all important. What is important is the message, which I think that our government is missing. The people want clear systemic changes, which our government is unable or unwilling to commit to.

You’ve lost the plot.

Yellow Snowball

The only reason that I decided to come home to Malaysia is this – to fight for our future.

If there was one thing that my experiences at Bersih have taught me – it’s that there’s hope for Malaysia yet – one where people treat each other like people, where rights are respected and not trampled over, where one is able to make an honest living.

Our parents generation have failed us and as a result, our generation is saddled with all the mistakes of the past and it’s up to us to tackle the problems one by one. While some take the easy way out, to run away, or to hide elsewhere biding their time, I would have none of that.

Bersih 3.0 marks a turning point in our country’s future. No amount of violence and accusations will distract from this. Our people have changed and the country has been changed forever by this. No way will we be going back to the ways of the past.

All parties of our government need to take cognisance of this. Regardless of who comes to power in the next general elections, the landscape and people have changed forever. Whomever comes to power will have to realise that the rakyat no longer blindly trust the government.

This event also marks the rise of the middle-class, traditionally the drivers of all political change. Thanks to various education and economic opportunities provided in the past, we have a burgeoning middle-class who are educated enough to see through the many lies told by all sides and figure things out for ourselves.

A lot needs to be done to regain that trust and all parties must realise that, particularly our police force, who have become a force of authority to a farce of one. Same goes for the main-stream media whose censorship, distortion and lies only serve to stoke further anger and provoke incredulity.

I don’t know what the future holds but I’m sure of one thing – nothing is going to be the same after this.

The snowballing has begun.

Explanation Required

Watch this official video of the car accident from PDRM.

I saw what seemed like blood stains on the ground, near the driver side-door of the car. I do not know who it belongs to. I thought that it might have belonged to the police.

Now, this other video seems to show someone fighting off the crowds.

Maybe the police came out swinging and defended himself, fearing for his life. But why?

Now, watch this amateur video of the said accident from a different angle.

I saw what seemed like some people flying like bowling pins when they were hit by the police car, which seemed to be trying to brake.

Now, that puts a whole different spin on the story of the car accident.

Was it reasonable for the rally goers to throw stuff at the police car – or was it provoked?
Was it reasonable for the police car to speed away in a crowd – or was it negligent?

Ouch. My head hurts to think about it.

Aduhai Khaled Nordin

I just read this quote in an article in TheStar a few minutes ago claiming that “fewer students will be able to enter universities if the Government offers free education” and “only students with excellent results will have a chance to further their studies.”

Que FACEPALM!

Honestly, what are some of these cabinet ministers thinking (or not thinking). By implication, he is saying that the current system is the one that allows non-excellent students to further their studies. If it was taken away, these non-excellent students would not be able to go to University.

That explains a lot.

It explains why there are so many unemployed graduates in our country. It explains why the lecturers are complaining about the quality of their students. It explains the drop in standards and rankings of our local universities. It explains it all.

Our ivory towers are flooded by people who are not up to par.

As the Minister of Higher Education, he needs to take the necessary steps to ensure that only the excellent students go to university. That is the only way that we can restore the integrity and dignity into the system.

However, I don’t think that offering free education would make things better. I think that if education was free, the situation would only get worse as students would no longer be given the incentive to work hard and graduate fast, since it is free.

I hope that he does not run in the next GE.

Mansuh PTPTN

I’ll get straight to the point – I cannot possibly support the movement to abolish PTPTN.

The reason is simple enough, nobody forced these people to take a low interest rate education loan. Seriously. I feel that these people are a bunch of losers who are just trying to get out of their obligations to repay the loan. What’s worse is that if they had bothered to study hard and do well, they would have been given a free pass anyway.

So, these are a bunch of students who are unwilling to work for their studies and who want to get away with a free lunch. It just sickens me.

They are a bunch of selfish bozos who would rather saddle the rest of the country with more debt than to actually do the honourable thing and to repay their own debt. I personally know of many PTPTN receipients who have still not paid a sen of their debts even after working for many years. I try to counsel them to do so but they don’t feel the necessity to.

However, I made sure that my staff did not fall into this category. I made it very clear to them that they have to repay their PTPTN loans. I pay them well enough that they have no excuse not to repay the loan. It is a sad reflection on the character of a person if they do not repay their debts. I would not want to hire such people.

I too, am currently repaying my student loan. Incidentally, it’s about an order of magnitude more than the typical PTPTN loan. While it is extremely painful and stressful to pay it off, I am meeting my obligations on time and making damn well sure that I do not fall behind. It gets difficult at times but I am not going to owe anyone anything in life.

As for the argument for a free education, there is no such thing. Someone needs to pay for it. The argument that tertiary education needs to be free is hard to justify. Everyone already has free education up to the secondary level, which is more than enough to find work and live in this world. Nobody owes anyone advanced education.

If we make education free, someone still has to pay for it – the taxpayer.

I can support it if these students were fighting for better education e.g. better curriculum, better faculty, better experiences, etc. That would make perfect sense as they are merely demanding for better value for money – not to get free of their obligations. However, this is something that sickens me.

Our young are fast becoming too entitled – they feel that the world owes them a living. The fact is that, nobody does. The sooner they understand that, the sooner they will learn to work for things. A good life doesn’t come cheap and most definitely not without sacrifice.

Bersih 3.0

I think that it’ll be fun this time around. I’ll be encouraging my friends and colleagues to join too, as I feel that the risk of a crack down by the police is highly unlikely.

The government is caught between a rock and a hard place.

If they choose to let Bersih 3.0 happen, it may fizzle and die out or it may just embolden the ‘silent’ majority to let themselves be heard. If the event draws the huge crowds that it is expected to, it may just prove that the rakyat truly want change and until we get it, there will be more sequels coming soon.

If they choose to block the event and crack down on the rally goers, it may spell complete doom for the ruling government in the next GE. It is also likely to draw international condemnation if the government gases its own citizens for simply asking for electoral reform. Images of police brutality are unlikely to swing any votes their way.

I don’t want to be the cabinet at this time. It’s difficult to decide on what to do.

In this game, the only way to win might be to not play at all.

PS: I wish that the BN politicians and parties would come join the party too. It’d be fun.

NFC Fiasco

Fiasco is the right word that I’d use too. It’s what this National Feedlot Corporation mess has turned into. I often wonder why it is that our government does not take the bull by its horns. It had an opportunity to do the right thing, but now it’s past. Now, they are left to clean up the mess.

According to the TMI article, “Former senior police officer Datuk Mat Zain Ibrahim asserted today that the National Feedlot Corporation’s (NFCorp) controversial condominium purchases are clear examples of CBT (criminal breach of trust), adding the Attorney-General should have no doubt of this when deciding whether to press charges.”

“After having sighted the NFC (National Feedlot Centre) loan agreement that was made available yesterday, coupled with the public statement by the Commercial Crimes Investigations Director (CCID), I would say that the Attorney General’s Chambers should not have any doubts in their mind now, that these are clear cut case of CBTs by agent as defined under Section 409 (of the) Penal Code.”

“In an in intriguing twist to the ongoing NFC saga, CCID Director Datuk Syed Ismail Syed Azizan confirmed yesterday that the police would recommend CBT charges against all NFCorp directors to the Attorney-General’s Chambers.”

“Shahrizat’s son Wan Shahinur Izmir had explained that the company had decided that it would make better use of the money by investing in property during a break in business operations. The break, said Wan Shahinur Izmir, was caused by the government’s decision to suspend the construction of an abattoir that would have been rented to NFCorp.”

Honestly.

The first rule when you’re in this kind of hole is to stop digging. His mother should have taught him not to speak without counsel. The last thing that one should do is to go around admitting to the act and trying to justify their way out of it.

Her son has basically admitted to committing the act. Whether that act is a CBT is a question for the lawyers. It would seem that if both current and former police officers think that it is CBT, there might actually be something there.

The government needs to nip this while they still can before this turns into an bigger issue. Otherwise, they are definitely going to suffer. People are already fed up with multi-billion RM scandals, this one might just tip the balance.

PS: I feel sorry for Sharizat because I think that her chance for a come-back is totally dashed. She will have to sit out the next GE lest she serves as a constant reminder to the fiasco.